CatholicMatch Review for 2023

CatholicMatch is probably the best dating app out there for Catholic singles to find serious relationships with those who share the same faith and value system! This is a niche dating app that caters to a fairly specific market, so it is a smaller-scale operation. But that does not mean they can’t provide you with some massive results! As of 2022, they have about 1.5 million active users and their weekly visitors are somewhere around 500,000. That’s a pretty nice dating pool for a niche dating app!

So how good is Catholic Match overall as an online matchmaking service? Are they worth the time, money, and energy to become a member? We are going to be addressing these questions and more in our review. We are also going to touch on membership pricing and features as well as free trial offers that allow you to use the app free of charge!

CatholicMatch Banner - Couple Looking at Each Other

Catholic Match Ratings


Catholic Match has been in business since 1999 and has proven to be a major player in the online religious dating services market. They have been responsible for creating a ton of successful matches between Catholic singles for the past 20 years.

But how did we feel about this dating app? Check out our overall ratings for the CatholicMatch app to find out!

Category Score
User Friendliness 4
Quality of Matches 3.5
Total Userbase 3
Membership Features 4
Pricing 4

Pros and Cons of CatholicMatch

CatholicMatch might not be the best dating app for everyone reading this review. We are going to address good reasons to join CatholicMatch as well as reasons to not join. Essentially, we are going to go over the pros and cons of this dating app. If you are uncertain if CatholicMatch is the right place for you to find other singles, we encourage you to keep reading!

5 Reasons to Join Catholic Match

Reasons Details
Finding Singles of the Catholic Faith Everything you need to know about this dating app is in the name! This is one of the best matchmaking services out there for Catholic singles!
Finding Serious Relationships and Dating This is not a great dating app if you want something casual. CatholicMatch is designed to bring together like-minded singles who share the same faith for serious dating and committed long-term relationships.
Awesome Membership Features and Functions Where do we begin? There is the CatholicMatch forum, a great support system between members. There is unlimited messaging, a photo wall for newly uploaded user photos, and the ability to send emotigrams (icebreakers).
Thorough Personality Testing to Create Ideal Matches Although the sign-up process is time-consuming, it is extremely thorough. There are a ton of faith-based questions around subjects like the sanctity of life and mass attendance as well as questions around stuff like family, political views, habits, diet, and education.
Excellent Customer Service CatholicMatch, compared to a lot of other dating apps, has dynamic customer support. In addition to phone and email support, they have an awesome community forum where customers can support one another and answer questions.

5 Reasons to Not Join Catholic Match

Reasons Details
You Are Not Catholic We would not advise that you use this dating app if you are not of the Catholic faith. People use this site because they are seeking Catholic singles who share their values and faith.
You Live Want Casual Relationships or Dating This is definitely not the place to find casual dating scenarios or relationships. People using CatholicMatch are basically looking for long-term commitments like marriage or just serious relationships in general.
You Live in a Rural Area Because a lot of CatholicMatch’s matchmaking is done by location, you run the risk of not finding a whole lot of singles near you if you live in a more remote or rural area.
You Don’t Want to Deal With a Lengthy Sign-Up Process Sign-up and the personality tests that come with creating a new account at CatholicMatch are pretty time-consuming, taking anywhere from 15-20 minutes. This is one where you need to get through a large volume of questions.
Limited Free Trial Features There is not too much you can do with the CatholicMatch app’s free trial besides viewing others’ profiles, seeing who has viewed your profile and uploading 50 photos. There are no messaging capabilities whatsoever. We highly recommend getting a CatholicMatch membership. Overview

These are a few things that anyone who is interested in joining CatholicMatch should know! To be clear, CatholicMatch is a niche religious dating app. There are much smaller in scale than a site like Christian Mingle or eHarmony. The dating pools are going to be a lot smaller but also a lot more specific as well!

Fact Details
Site Name
Key Info Best For: finding Catholic singles who are looking for serious, faith-based relationships
Active Members: 1.5 million
Weekly Traffic: 500,000
Gender Ratio: 50% men and 50% women
Matchmaking System: CatholicMatch creates matches based on your location
Free Trial Yes
Membership Pricing Starting at $9.99/month

Free Trial Availability

If you want to give CatholicMatch a try but do not spend any money in the process, we encourage you to check out the CatholicMatch free trial offer. You can test drive this dating app and no money will come out of your account! Begin by clicking on the link below or visiting the homepage of their site. There will be a big blue button right in the middle saying Get Started For Free.

Free Trial Features

So what can you do with a free trial at CatholicMatch? Well, as it turns out, not too much! This is a dating app where the free trial is pretty limited compared to a lot of the other free trial offers we have seen at bigger dating apps like eHarmony, Match, and Christian Mingle.

The entire point of a free trial is to get future users interested in a CatholicMatch membership. The free trial is never meant to be a way that you can use the dating app in its entirety for free.

But we do feel that the free trial is one of the weaker areas of our CatholicMatch reviews. We have reviewed dating apps with free trials that allow trial users to send some messages back and forth with other singles. We would love to see CatholicMatch add a few more features to their free trial to give future users more of a taste of what they can expect on the app.

Membership Plans and Prices

There are a few membership plans that you can pursue at CatholicMatch. Each has the same features, but they are going to vary in length. Note that shorter plans are going to have a higher monthly cost than the longer ones, so choose your plan wisely. There are definitely some savings there to be had!

1 Month


6 Month


12 Month


What Comes With a Membership?

All membership plans come with the same features. The only thing that is different is the membership plan lengths. No matter which plans you settle on, you can enjoy this full range of features and functions for finding Catholic Singles.

Customer Service and Support

One of the biggest strengths of CatholicMatch was its customer service and support center. We have reviewed a lot of other dating apps in the past and a lot of them have an FAQ center on their help page and nothing more. But CatholicMatch offers their customers five different options! That is excellent in our book!

We even tested out the support systems and we received quick and friendly service! We found that we could have our questions answered or concerns addressed within 24 hours or less by the CatholicMatch support center. This is a far cry from the normal dating app support centers we have seen in the past!

Support Systems at CatholicMatch:

Sign Up Process

If you are ready to begin your journey using CatholicMatch, begin by starting a new account today! We will give you step-by-step instructions on how to start and go through the sign-up process. it is pretty self-explanatory, but it is definitely one of the most in-depth sign-up processes we have seen!

Begin by visiting the homepage. You can start by clicking on the Get Started for Free button right in the middle. Even if you are interested in doing a paid membership, you will want to begin by clicking that button. Whether you are paying or using the app for free, the sign-up process is the same.

Provide your email address and create a unique password. Also, be sure to agree to the terms and conditions of CatholicMatch before hitting Continue!

This portion of sign-up captures some initial information about who you are.

  • What is your first and last name?
  • What is your location?
  • What is your gender?
  • What is your marital status?
  • What is your date of birth?
  • What Diocese are you in?

The questions become a little more detailed here.

  • What is your height?
  • What is your ethnicity?
  • Do you drink alcohol?
  • Do you smoke or use tobacco?
  • Do you have any children?
  • What are your political views?
  • What is your education?
  • What is your line of work?

Now we get into the meat of the questionnaire! We begin seeing a lot more questions about the Catholic faith.

  • How much do you practice your faith?
  • How often do you attend mass?
  • What liturgical style do you prefer?
  • Do you accept the Church’s teachings on the Eucharist?
  • Do you accept the Church’s teachings on Contraception?
  • Do you accept the Church’s teachings on the Sanctity of Life?
  • Do you accept the Church’s teachings on Premarital Sex?

In this step, you get the chance to describe yourself a little better. Keep in mind there is a 50-character minimum requirement and a maximum of 500. Here is your chance to shine with a tagline that really pops!

This step involves telling CatholicMatch about what kind of activities you enjoy (good convversations, trying new things, sightseeing, visiting beaches, etc.), what kind of music you listen to (country music,,, and your ideal travel destinations.

Add some photos of yourself. With a free trial, you can add up to 50! You have the option of adding photos from your device or even your Facebook account!

Now you have the choice of continuing with your free trial or paying for a membership with CatholicMatch! Choose wisely. There are a lot more features and benefits with a paid membership like messaging capabilities.

CatholicMatch Reviews From Users

We want to give our readers a good idea of what CatholicMatch users have experienced in the past and present some of their general thoughts toward the dating app. We looked all over the internet for some Catholic dating site reviews on CatholicMatch and here is what we found!

Read More
“People on this subreddit are generally pretty negative on CM, perhaps rightly so. It’s been well over a year since I’ve used the site, but I did meet my fiancé on it, so I am a success story. If you’re in a well-populated area I think you’ll tend to have better luck. They also do various sales around holidays throughout the year, so I would wait to purchase a subscription until then because you can typically get six months for about $10-15 per month. Nothing is a guarantee, so if you do purchase a subscription then give it a good faith effort. Fill out your entire profile and add multiple good photos. Log in every day and message someone, don’t get attached to any one specific profile, and be willing to broaden your search terms. In the end, if it doesn’t work, you’ll have at least tried and you won’t be wondering what might have happened otherwise.”
Anonymous User
Anonymous User2019
Read More
“Good for Catholics. Works, but did not find anyone I was particularly interested in having a serious relationship with. Good for Catholics and May God bless you all. Contacted support and they did sort out my issues eventually. Still waiting for a refund for the rest of the 5 months to drop in my account. Use the cc button on the bottom right for English subtitles. Hilarious.”
Jake O.
Jake O.2021
Read More
“My wife and I met 10 1/2 years ago on Catholic Match. We both agree it was the most amazing thing that has happened in our life. Her photos were fuzzy, but we messaged back and forth for some time. I truly believe God had our happiness in mind. She was everything I asked for times 100. I will forever be in debt to Catholic Match. Unfortunately, you need to skim through the people that are untruthful to find the precious gem God has in store for you. GOOD LUCK to all of you.”
Read More
“I used Catholic Match, and I didn't think it was all that great. There just weren't a lot of people in my area. I suppose I could've done a long-distance relationship, but I've done that before and had no interest in doing that again. I honestly just find it exhausting trying to meet people over an app instead of in person. It takes so much more effort to have quality conversations over messaging. I finally ended my subscription, deleted my account, and removed the app from my phone. Catholic Match wasn't the right fit for me, but I'm sure my experience isn't universal. It was probably great for some folks which I think's great! But yeah, not for me. Anyway, I just wanted to give you my personal, honest review.”

Alternatives to CatholicMatch

Although CatholicMatch is a great dating app for finding other Catholic singles, the truth of the matter might be that it is not the right matchmaking service for you. And that is ok! We want you to be using the best app for finding the right singles.

Here are some of the best alternatives you can find on the market to In nearly all cases, you can find larger dating pools and better search filters at these alternative sites!

#1: Christian Mingle: Best for Finding Christians

Christian Mingle is probably the best alternative to CatholicMatch overall. By using Christian Mingle, you have a good chance of meeting some Catholic members. They might not be the majority of users at Christian Mingle, but they are still there, nonetheless. It helps that this Christian dating app has a large user base of over 15 million members, so there is so good potential there!

Christian Mingle Sign up Screen

#2: eHarmony: Best for Compatibility

eHarmony is a dating app that has users from all walks of life, faiths, lifestyles, and value systems! They are one of the biggest and most popular online matchmakers with over 60 million active users. Not only do they use compatibility-driven testing, but they have advanced search filters to break down searches by subjects like values, behavior, and beliefs!

eHarmony Homepage Screenshot

#3: Match: Best Filters to Customize Your Search

Like eHarmony, features a larger pool of potential candidates and uses some detailed search filtering that can help you to find singles of all different faiths including the Catholic faith! Match is also a great dating app for finding serious relationships, making this one of the better alternatives for those looking for Catholic singles. Homepage Screenshot

CatholicMatch Reviews FAQ

We feel that CatholicMatch is well worth the time and money if you are Catholic and are looking for other singles who share the same faith and values as you! It is definitely not a good dating app for people who are non-religious or looking for casual relationships. CatholicMatch is geared toward developing serious relationships between Catholic singles, so if this sounds like you, we highly recommend checking it out! While a site like Christian Mingle could also help you to find Catholic singles, CatholicMatch will help you find Catholic singles every single time!

You can trust this to be completely honest and transparent, primarily because we addressed both the good and bad aspects of this dating app. If we found something that we did not like about the site, we were eager to point that out and offer our feedback on how it could be made better or more user-friendly in the future. But we also gave praise to other areas of the site as well. We feel that this CatholicMatch online dating review is fair and balanced. Overall, we recommend this dating app to our readers, but it is definitely not perfect!

Yes, there have been plenty of users who have used CatholicMatch and found great success in finding true love or a serious, faith-based relationship. The one thing to keep in mind about CatholicMatch is that it is a smaller site, a niche dating app for specifically finding people who are of the Catholic faith. A site like eHarmony, Match, or even Christian Mingle is more likely to give you a larger pool of results. You might get more matches going with those dating apps, but there is also a chance that you are going to find non-Catholic singles too.

Something we encourage our readers to check out is the CatholicMatch success stories. When you go to sign in, there will be a link at the top left-hand corner of that page that will lead you to customer testimonials that will inspire you. If you have any doubt about CatholicMatch working for you, give one of the success stories a read.

Yes, there is a free trial available to CatholicMatch newcomers where they can test out the site to see if it is worth their time and money. We found that this is one of the more restricted free trials that we have run across. The only features you can enjoy with a free CatholicMatch account are setting up your own personal profile, searching and viewing other profiles, seeing whom you have matched with, seeing who has viewed your profile, uploading around 50 photos, and sending “emotigrams” to generate interest with other users. 

There are three membership plans to be found at CatholicMatch: a 1-month membership, a 6-month membership, and a 12-month membership. The 1-month membership costs $29.99 per month. The 6-month membership costs $14.99 per month for a grand total of $89.94. The 12-month membership costs $9.99 per month for a grand total of $119.88 for the entire year.

We personally tested out the CatholicMatch app and found out quickly that we had nothing to worry about! The app uses an encrypted connection in its operating system to safeguard any personal or financial information that is shared with the site. We also found that CatholicMatch uses an excellent vetting system to keep fake accounts, bots, or scammers at bay. There are some that slip through the vetting system, but CatholicMatch, we saw, is diligent at pinpointing any weird activity and putting an end to that.

With a CatholicMatch membership, you will be able to have access to a community chat room, enjoy unlimited messaging with any other profile at the site, and get a higher level of service from the customer support department. Another perk of being a member is the ability to send personalized emotigrams! We highly recommend membership at CatholicMatch. The free trial is not a viable way to meet other Catholic singles (primarily due to the fact that there are really no ways to send messages).

Something we noticed about the CatholicMatch app was how easy it was to sign up and then how easy the entire site was to use! We tested out the sign-up process for both free trial and membership accounts, and we were able to complete everything in around 5 to 10 minutes. Something that makes sign-up even easier is if you use Facebook! A lot of your information will transfer to your new CatholicMatch account automatically, really cutting down on the time to answer the new customer questionnaire.

Once we were on the site, we found that it was really easy to navigate other singles’ profiles. Everything was laid out in a clear and organized fashion!

The only difference that we could see between the three membership offers at CatholicMatch was the plan length: 1 month, 6 months, and 12 months. As far as we can tell, you get all the same membership features regardless of the plan length. Readers might want to note that the monthly rate is cheaper going with one of the longer plans compared to getting a single-month membership!

As of 2023, there are around 1.5 million users who actively use CatholicMatch! For a little niche dating app, that is a pretty impressive number. While you are guaranteed to find singles who will share your Catholic faith, you are not going to get the vast and varied results that you might find on a dating app like Christian Mingle. But if finding singles who see eye to eye with you on faith is something that matters deeply to you, CatholicMatch is definitely the way to go!

One of the best features of the CatholicMatch app is the fact that they have a dead-even ratio of men to women! There are plenty of dating apps out there that are worth passing up on because the ratios or so out of whack, but CatholicMatch certainly is not one of them! e